It is the ultimate lunch packing nightmare. You open your bag, and instead of finding your laptop and paperwork, you find a puddle of chicken noodle soup.
Bentgo has built its reputation on being the premier leak proof lunch box. Their marketing videos show people shaking the boxes upside down with nothing spilling out.
But this leads to a dangerous question that many users ask too late: Can you actually put soup in a Bentgo box?
We put the seals to the test to distinguish between marketing claims and real-world physics. Here is the honest breakdown.
The Definition: “Leak-Proof” vs. “Water-Tight”
To understand the test, you have to understand the engineering.
The classic Bentgo models (Kids, Fresh, and Modern) use a compression seal technology. A silicone ridge on the lid presses down onto the plastic tray.
- Viscous Liquids (Safe): The seal is designed to hold thick liquids. Hummus, yogurt, ranch dressing, and ketchup. These have high surface tension.
- Watery Liquids (Unsafe): Water, juice, broth, and thin vinaigrettes. These have low surface tension and can “creep” through microscopic gaps if the box is squeezed or bent.
The Test Results by Model
Not all Bentgo boxes are created equal. We analyzed how different models handle the “Soup Challenge.”
1. Bentgo Kids / Bentgo Fresh / Bentgo Modern
These are the flat, bento-style boxes.
- Thick Stews/Chili: YES. If your soup is chunky (like a beef stew or a thick potato chowder) and has the consistency of oatmeal, it will stay put.
- Broth/Ramen: NO. Do not do it. If the box is compressed in a tight backpack, the flexible outer shell can warp slightly, breaking the seal for a split second enough for broth to leak.
- Temperature Warning: If you put boiling hot soup in, the steam creates pressure inside the box. As it cools, it creates a vacuum that might suck the seal inwards or, conversely, the pressure might blow the seal open.
2. Bentgo Salad Container
This is a popular model for adults.
- The Bottom Bowl: YES. The large bottom bowl of the Bentgo Salad container is designed to hold greens, but it is deep and has a robust locking clip system with a rubber gasket. It can handle soups, provided the container is kept relatively upright.
- The Top Tray: NO. Do not put liquids in the top compartment tray. That section is for dry toppings (croutons, chicken).
3. Bentgo Bowl
- The Verdict: YES. This is the only model explicitly designed for this. It has a screw-top lid (threaded) rather than a compression lid (snapped). Screw-tops are the only true defense against watery soup.
The “Viscosity Rule”
Before you pour, perform the “Spoon Test.”
- Dip a spoon into your lunch.
- Tilt the spoon.
- If it drips like water: It belongs in a thermos or a screw-top jar.
- If it globs like ketchup: It is safe for your leak proof lunch box.
Summary: What Can You Pack?
To keep your bag dry, follow this cheat sheet:
| Food Item | Bentgo Kids/Fresh/Modern | Bentgo Salad Bowl |
| Hummus / Dip | ✅ Safe | ✅ Safe |
| Yogurt | ✅ Safe | ✅ Safe |
| Thick Chili | ⚠️ Caution (Cool down first) | ✅ Safe |
| Tomato Soup | ❌ RISKY | ✅ Safe |
| Chicken Broth | ❌ DO NOT PACK | ✅ Safe |
| Watermelon Juice | ❌ DO NOT PACK | ✅ Safe |
Can you put soup in a Bentgo box?
If you are using the standard bento-style boxes, the answer is no. They are “sauce-proof,” not “soup-proof.” For liquids that slosh, you need a threaded lid.
If you want to pack soup, buy the Bentgo Bowl or a separate stainless steel thermos. Don’t risk your laptop for a bowl of ramen.
read more: Pantry Makeover: Organizing Dry Goods with Rubbermaid Brilliance Canisters
[…] what makes your Bentgo container so great. It’s compartmentalized to allow for “Bistro Style” lunches—packs of variety […]
[…] Some containers that have lids are not completely airtight. For example, a regular cookie jar that you screw the top on and off or a nice ceramic container to hold things; these often do not have a seal to keep the air out. […]