We put a lot of time into making sure we have the amount of butter and flour in our cookies. Then we often mess them up when we store the cookies. This is the part where we can really ruin our cookies, the cookies.
People think that vintage ceramic cookie jars are the thing to have in the kitchen. They look really nice on the counter. Remind us of the past. When we think about how well they work, vintage ceramic cookie jars are not good at keeping food fresh. The problem is the lid on ceramic cookie jars. It is heavy. Does not have a special seal to keep air out. This means that moisture can easily get into ceramic cookie jars and make the food go bad.
If you want your biscotti to stay hard and your chewy cookies to stay chewy you need to stop looking at the pattern on the ceramic. You should start looking at the shore hardness of the silicone seal. This is because the shore hardness of the silicone seal is really important for your biscotti and chewy cookies. The shore hardness of the silicone seal will help your biscotti stay hard and your chewy cookies stay chewy.
Here is the breakdown of the best airtight cookie containers that balance countertop aesthetics with actual pneumatic performance.
The Physics of “Stale”: Why Cookies Fail
Before you buy a container you really need to know what you are up against, which is the enemy, the container’s weaknesses, and the enemy. So you have to think about the enemy and what the enemy can do to the container. The enemy is important when it comes to buying a container.
- Crisp Cookies like Oreos and Biscotti get stale fast. This happens because they absorb moisture from the air. Crisp Cookies need to be stored in a place with no moisture at all. This will help keep Crisp Cookies like Oreos and Biscotti fresh for a time.
- Chewy Cookies are really good when they are fresh. The problem with Chewy Cookies is that they go stale. This happens because Chewy Cookies lose moisture to the air around them. To keep Chewy Cookies fresh you need to store them in a container that keeps the air from getting in. This container needs to be able to keep the moisture in so Chewy Cookies stay soft and chewy. A high-humidity seal is what Chewy Cookies need to stay fresh for a time.
So, in both situations, the thing that matters is air exchange. You need a container that is sealed tightly. Something that a lot of those cute cookie jars just do not have.
The Contenders: Engineered for the Countertop
We looked at three choices to see how well they were sealed, how easy they were to get into and how nice they looked. We wanted to know if you could get your hand into the cookie jar easily so we called this the “Cookie Jar Hand” factor. We also thought about how good they looked because the cookie jar should be nice to look at too.
1. The Accessibility King: OXO Good Grips POP Cookie Jar
Most airtight containers are rectangles that you can put in your cupboards. OXO used their POP technology. Made it into a classic round shape, like a fishbowl, that is perfect for your countertops. This way you can see what is inside the OXO containers. They look nice on your countertops. The OXO containers are really good for storing things.
- The Mechanism: This thing works with a button. When the button is up you can get to the handle. When you push the button down a soft silicone part called a flange gets bigger and presses against the wall, which is usually made of glass or plastic. The Mechanism uses this button to control the handle and the silicone flange.
- The Aesthetic: It looks modern. It is very clean and clear. The cookies are on display and that is a big part of the design. The cookies themselves are a design element that people will notice.
- The Verdict: This is the option for households that go through things quickly. The container has a seal for storing cookies that you will eat in the next two weeks. But it is not the seal it is just a friction seal, not a clamp. So if your kitchen gets really hot or cold the seal might not be as tight after a while. This container is really good for families with kids because the plastic body is very strong.
2. The Heavy-Duty Classic: Le Parfait Super Jar (or Kilner)
To keep things good for a long time like several months you need to stop using the push-button and go back to using mechanical leverage. This is the way you can get absolute preservation for months. You have to use leverage instead of the push-button.
- The Mechanism: These things work with a wire that goes around and squeezes hard on a special rubber seal. It is a rough way to make sure something is airtight. The wire bail system is what makes the rubber gasket get pressed tightly which is how these things make sure everything stays inside. The rubber gasket is made to be strong because it is vulcanized.
- The Aesthetic: The look of this thing is really nice. It has an old-fashioned feel to it like a bakery you might find in France. The Aesthetic of this thing is great. When you put The Aesthetic on a granite countertop The Aesthetic looks like it is well made. It looks like it will last a long time.
- The Verdict: The opening of this thing is pretty small which makes it tough to get the cookie out without getting your hand stuck. When it comes to keeping things fresh it is really good. If you make a lot of biscotti and you need them to last for a month then this is the thing you should use for storing your biscotti.
3. The Modern Minimalist: Brabantia Window Canister
People who think clear plastic is not wire clamps are too old fashioned the Brabantia steel line is a good choice. It is something in between. The Brabantia steel line is an option for these people.
- The Mechanism: A kind of lid called a “flavor-seal” click lid. This flavor-seal click lid is not too harsh like a clamp. It is tighter than a regular ceramic lid. The flavor-seal click lid is something in between you know, not too loose and not too tight.
- The Aesthetic: The look of this thing is really nice. It is made of a kind of steel that does not get fingerprints on it. The steel is matte. It has a small window. This window is useful because it lets you see how stuff you have inside without showing all the crumbs and mess. The Aesthetic of this thing is great because it hides the crumbs while still showing you the inventory level of the stuff you have.
- The Verdict: This thing is great for kitchens that have an industrial style. It keeps the cookies away from sunlight, which is good because sunlight can make the chocolate chips go bad. This means the cookies will taste better for longer which is a little better than using jars for storing cookies like chocolate chip cookies.
The “Sugar Cube” Hack
The best cookie containers that keep air out still cannot stop the air that gets trapped inside the cookie container when you put the lid on. The air that is already inside the cookie container is still there with a really good lid on the cookie container.
To engineer the perfect humidity level, stop relying solely on the container:
- For Soft Cookies: Throw a slice of bread into the container with your Soft Cookies. Alternatively you can use a sugar keeper, which is usually a small terracotta disc. The white bread or the terracotta disc from the brown sugar keeper acts like a humidifier. It releases moisture into the air, which helps to keep your Soft Cookies soft.
- For Crisp Cookies: Add a silica gel packet, the kind that’s safe to use with food, to the bottom of the jar. This silica gel packet is really helpful because it keeps the air dry. It does this by absorbing any moisture that gets in when you open the lid of the jar. This way your Crisp Cookies will stay fresh.
Final Recommendation
If you have kids and the cookies disappear in 3 days, get the OXO POP Cookie Jar for the ease of use. If you are baking for longevity or living in a very humid climate, trust the mechanical seal of a Glass Clamp Jar. Everything else is just decoration.
[…] thing that is most frustrating when shopping for storage containers online is trying to determine if your groceries will indeed fit into the containers that you are […]
[…] Then we often mess them up when we store the cookies. This is the part where we can really ruin our cookies, the […]