The Anchor Hocking Heritage Hill jar really looks just like how a cookie jar is supposed to. The jar has thick clear glass and a wide mouth, topped with a heavy glass lid that features a big knob. It’s been made in Lancaster, Ohio since 1905. It sells over 7,000 units every month and has 10,943 ratings. It fits right in on the kitchen counter, like it’s meant to be there.
- INCLUDES: This Anchor Hocking glass jar set contains (2) 1-gallon Heritage Hill jars with (2) glass lids. All-clear glas…
- USE: These glass jars are perfect to store all manner of dry goods including flour, cookies, rice, coffee, spices, candy…
- DURABLE: These glass jars with matching lids are wide mouthed and thick walled to ease scooping and maximize protection….
Just a heads-up before you get it for storing cookies: it’s not airtight.
What the Listing Really Says
Anchor Hocking is honest about this. The product description says: “Even though these containers don’t have a suction seal, their thick, oversized glass lids still do a good job of covering and protecting your food and drinks.” That sentence is easy to miss when you’re just glancing at photos of pretty glass jars full of cookies.
The lid rests on the jar, glass against glass, kept in place just by gravity and its own weight. There’s no silicone gasket, no O-ring, and no locking mechanism. It does the job. It doesn’t seal properly.
For buyers who take the time to read carefully, this works just fine. Karen Ruth bought them on purpose for sourdough starter because the lid lets air in. That’s actually needed for fermentation, not a mistake. Roget uses them to make kombucha for the same reason. The jar works just like it claims.
The problem is when people buy it thinking it will work perfectly without any issues. Chris Montgomery said he didn’t read the description and felt let down. Nena gave it four stars and said, “I wish the lids had a silicone seal.” One anonymous reviewer said it straight up: “The glass is good quality, but the lids don’t seal airtight.”
What It Really Does Well
If you forget about the airtight claim for a moment, the Heritage Hill jar really does a great job at a bunch of other things.
Capacity is the clear factor here. Each jar holds one gallon, and since the set comes with two jars, you can store a whole batch of cookies without any squeezing. Jem says they’re “absolutely perfect as cookie jars,” especially liking the wide mouth because it makes filling and cleaning a breeze, and the size is just right for holding a good batch. Pandora’s Mom packs them with cookies, ties a bow around the neck, and hands them out as hostess gifts.
The glass is thick and heavy, and you can put the whole jar, lid and all, in the dishwasher without any problem. Carmel Perry bought them because her husband has severe rheumatoid arthritis and can’t manage a silicone-sealed lid. No gasket, no latch, no problem at all. It’s worth mentioning the accessibility part because the competitors who have it locked down just can’t match that.
Laura L. Johnsen keeps one handy on the counter for granola bars and snacks. GM Blue Eyes stores crackers, peanuts, and granola bars in the cabinet above. For dry goods that people use up in just a few days, the glass lid does a good job of keeping them fresh between uses.
The Honest Position
The Heritage Hill jar is good enough for cookies you plan to eat within two or three days. The lid helps keep dust, bugs, and everyday air from getting inside. It doesn’t keep the humidity as well as a silicone-sealed jar does, but if your household eats cookies fast, that difference doesn’t really make much of a difference.
If you want your cookies to stay fresh for a week or more, not sealing them properly will mess with their texture. Crispy cookies end up getting soft, while chewy ones tend to become hard. The jar might look right, but it just can’t keep things fresh like airtight containers do.
Get it if you need a big, nice-looking jar that can hold a full batch and is safe to put in the dishwasher. If keeping things fresh longer matters more, you might want to pick something else.
[…] 16 oz jar can fit about 8 to 10 medium-sized cookies. That’s just one serving, not a whole batch. If […]
[…] hot water on them. This vacuum seal actually keeps things fresher way longer than just a normal sealed jar. For keeping things fresh over a longer stretch, like two to four weeks, this works better than […]
[…] coffee is freshly roasted, it lets out carbon dioxide. When you put coffee in a glass jar, the gas gets stuck inside, and that can make your coffee go stale. That tiny plastic valve right […]