So, you’re shopping for a salad spinner on Amazon, huh? Right away, you’re gonna notice there are two really big names kinda going head-to-head.
- One-Touch OXO Salad Spinner: Did you know that OXO invented the one-touch salad spinner? Its one-handed pump gives you m…
- What Makes the OXO Salad Spinner OXO Better: This salad spinner has been designed to be the best – from the one-touch pr…
- Store Salad Spinner Neatly After Use: When you’re done using the spinner as a fruit and vegetable cleaner, press the pum…
In the red corner, the clear winner: The OXO Good Grips (6.22 quarts). It’s pretty well-known for that “pump” thing it invented and it always seems to be at the top of the best-seller charts.
- QUICK & CONVENIENT: Wash and spin-dry salad greens, fruits, and vegetables effortlessly with the Cuisinart 3qt Salad Spi…
- USER FRIENDLY: Easy-to-use spin knob allows for quick and efficient spinning action. Conveniently add and drain water wi…
- STABILITY: Non-skid base keeps the bowl stable and prevents any unwanted movement and mess.
In the blue corner, we’ve got the challenger: The Cuisinart Salad Spinner, coming in at three quarts. It still spins the old-fashioned way, but they say it’s more compact and a breeze to clean.
They’re both supposed to keep your lettuce from getting all soggy. When you look at how they work and their vastly different sizes, it makes you wonder which one really deserves a spot in your limited cabinet space.
We looked at the G-force, how clean things came out, and what actual people using it had to say from people making latkes to those just eating salad for themselves and then we picked a winner.
The Contender 1: The OXO Good Grips (The Pump)
Everyone pretty much agrees the OXO is the gold standard. It’s mostly known for that big black button right on top.
The Mechanism So, with this thing, you don’t crank a handle; you actually push a pump. It’s got a ratchet system that makes the basket spin. What’s great about it is how comfy it feels to hold. You can use it with one hand. It also has a special brake button that stops the basket right away.
The pump flattens out, so it’s easy to store in the fridge or cabinet. You can even stack them, which is a real space saver.
Real User Experience It’s not just for lettuce. User D. Vanco, whose purchase of the Large 6.22-quart model was verified, really shows how tough the mechanism is:
“I even used it to get water out of shredded potatoes for things like latkes and hash browns, and it did a great job there too. That thing can spin really fast.”
Vanco also mentioned, “the way it’s built and the stuff it’s made from make me think… It’s going to stick around for ages.” This is a big deal because when you’re dealing with something heavy, like a bag of potatoes, cheaper gears just break. The OXO lives on.
The Contender 2: The Cuisinart Salad Spinner (The Crank/Knob)
So, OXO is all about being big and strong, but Cuisinart is more about making things easy and clean.
The Mechanism How it works is pretty simple: you just turn the knob or crank on top by hand to get it going.
- Pros: You get to control the speed more directly. Plus, the top lets you add and drain water without even taking off the lid—that’s for both washing and spinning.
Hygiene is Cuisinart’s secret weapon. The lid separates. Cici, one of our actual customers, got the 3-quart model and pointed out something really neat. She said Cuisinart fixed a problem that’s pretty common in a lot of other spinners out there:
“I love that you can take the lid apart for cleaning; that’s actually a pretty big deal to me.”
Cici mentioned how the size is great for smaller households: “I have a bigger one… but sometimes I want to make a personal salad for myself… This was just what I needed.”
Head-to-Head Comparison
Let’s stack these up against each other.
1. The Capacity War (6.22qt vs. 3qt)
This is the biggest difference.
- The OXO is really something else. You can just throw in two whole heads of Romaine lettuce, no problem. It’s a “Family Size” tool.
- The Cuisinart (3qt) is small. It holds about half a head of lettuce. It’s just right for a “Lunch for One.”
(Note: The 3-quart Cuisinart is the one everyone buys because it’s so easy to move around, even though there’s a 5-quart option too.)
2. The Mechanism (Pump vs. Crank)
- The Pump (OXO): Totally wins when it comes to how easy it is to use. If you have arthritis or your hand strength isn’t what it used to be, this pump is super easy to use.
- The Crank (Cuisinart): A winner for its straightforward design. Less stuff to break, sure, but you’ll have to put in more work to really get it going fast.
3. Cleaning
People kept complaining for ages that mold would get stuck in the OXO lid. OXO has gotten better about this in its newer models, but Cuisinart really nails it: you can totally separate the lid. If you’re really particular about germs, Cuisinart can help you feel a lot more at ease.
The Verdict: Which one should you buy?
They’re both truly great products, five-star worthy even, but they’re not for everyone.
Buy the OXO Good Grips If:
- You have a family to feed: You really need that 6.22-quart capacity to dry a really big salad all at once.
- You want versatility: As user D. Vanco mentioned, drying heavy things like potatoes for hash browns requires a tough tool.
- You care about comfort: The one-handed pump is the best out there.
Buy the Cuisinart Salad Spinner If:
- You cook for one or two: The 3-quart size is ideal. It’s great for making “personal salads” and won’t take up too much space in your dishwasher.
- Your kitchen is tiny: It’s practically half the size of an OXO.
- Hygiene is essential: You definitely want a lid that comes apart easily for a good, thorough cleaning.
Who won? When it comes to top-tier performance and sheer capacity, the OXO Good Grips is still the king. But if you don’t have much space, the Cuisinart is a good option, and it’s easier to clean, which is a plus.
[…] all the kitchen tools out there, the salad spinner definitely stirs up the most debate. Some home cooks really can’t do without it for their […]