Every parent will recognize the scenario. You prepare a yummy warm lunch nuggets, mac ‘n cheese, or leftovers and by lunchtime, it’s a warm-but unappetizing goo.
When hunting down a solution that reigns supreme on the playground, there are two contenders that top the list: the omnipresent Bentgo lunch box and the heavy-duty OmieBox.
But what’s interesting is this: Both contenders position themselves as the better lunch box option despite being designed for radically different functions. So if you’re asking which solution will better keep lunches warm? The answer isn’t even a contest.
In this comparative analysis, we’re going to explore the science behind both solutions their advertised ‘leak-resistant design’ and ergonomics providing an informed guide on which box belongs in the backpack.
The “Heat Test”: Warmth Retention
Let’s get down to business right away.
The OmieBox: The Hot Specialist
The first interesting fact about the OmieBox is that it comes pre-loaded with a vacuum-sealed thermos container made of high-quality stainless steel.
- How it Works: Boil water and pour it into the thermos for five minutes to prime it. Drain it out. Fill it with hot food and lock it.
- The Result: This will keep food ‘warm’ for some 4 to 6 hours. It won’t be piping hot at lunchtime, but it will remain safe and warm.
- Bonus: You can pack warm noodles and cold fruits into the same box side-by-side since the thermos is isolated.
The Bentgo (Kids/Fresh/Chill): The Cold Warrior
The standard Bentgo lunch boxes are made of ABS Plastic equipped with a silicone seal.
- The Truth: A standard Bento box boasts zero thermal insulation properties.
- The Result: If you pack nuggets warmed at 7:00 AM, by 12:00 PM they will be room temperature. Moreover, the box specifically warns against packing extremely hot food as it may create a vacuum seal that prevents opening.
Winner: OmieBox (By a landslide).
The “Leak-Proof” Factor
While OmieBox wins on heat, does it hold liquids?
- Bentgo: This takes the cake. The rubber seal on the top completely creates separate compartments. You can put ranch dressing next to a sandwich, and they will never touch. It is foolproof.
- OmieBox: The thermos is “Leak-proof” if (and only if) the lid is seated correctly. However, the side compartments are “leak-resistant” rather than “leak-proof.” If you put applesauce in the side square and the box gets jostled, you might have a mess.
Winner: Bentgo.
Weight and Usability (The “Backpack” Test)
This is the critical part of the comparison which parents tend to overlook until they are shoulder-deep in boxes.
- OmieBox Weight: The OmieBox weighs 1.7 pounds empty. That is a full backpack’s worth of heavy. Add the food, and the preschooler’s backpack becomes burdensome. Also, the thermos lid requires decent wrist strength to unscrew.
- Bentgo Weight: The Bentgo Kids version weighs about 1.2 pounds. It uses two easy-turn latches that allow even a 3-year-old to access the contents in seconds.
Winner: Bentgo.
Comparison at a Glance
| Feature | Bentgo Lunch Box (Kids/Prints) | OmieBox |
| Keeps Food Hot? | No (Cold/Room Temp only) | Yes (Thermos included) |
| Keeps Food Cold? | Yes (Especially “Bentgo Chill”) | Yes (Side compartments) |
| Leak-Proof? | 100% (Individual compartments) | Only the thermos; sides vary |
| Weight | Lightweight | Heavy (Bulky) |
| Dishwasher Safe? | Tray only (Hand wash shell) | High Maintenance (Hand wash) |
| Best For… | Picky eaters / Grazing | Hot lunch fans (Pasta/Soup) |
The “Bentgo Hack” (If You Want Both)
For those fans of the Bentgo layout who want the convenience of a hot lunch without overloading the backpack:
The Expert’s Hack:
For cold lunches, the regular Bentgo is sufficient. For hot days, buy a separate, small thermos (like a Thermos Funtainer) and pack it alongside the Bentgo. Yes, it’s two items to carry, but it guarantees the Bentgo won’t warp and the food stays hot.
Final Verdict: Which to Buy?
Choose the OmieBox if:
Your child will not willingly consume anything cold. If hot meals like nuggets, mac-‘n-cheese, or soup are a daily requirement, the weight is worth it.
Choose the Bentgo if:
Your child is a grazer who likes variety (cheese, crackers, fruit). It is lighter, easier to open, and completely leak-proof for dips and sauces.
[…] read more: Bentgo vs. OmieBox: Which Lunch Box Keeps Food Warm Better? […]
[…] put brown sugar in a special container made by OXO called a POP container. We compared it to sugar that we stored in a really cheap jar that you have to screw the top on and […]